Comparison Manual testing

Crossfyre vs Caido

A cross-platform proxy with plugins vs a young Linux proxy attached to a scanning platform.

Caido is a web security testing toolkit built in Rust: an intercepting proxy with Replay, Automate, a query language for history, workflows and a plugin store, on Windows, macOS and Linux. The fair comparison on our side is the Crossfyre Workbench, a Linux desktop proxy at version 0.1.1. The Workbench is narrower: HTTP/1.1 only, no WebSockets, no fuzzer and no plugins. What it has of its own is replay as another user, scope enforcement and a findings report on a paid plan, free tools that need no account, and the Crossfyre platform beside it for recon and scanning.

Pick Caido if

You are choosing a proxy and nothing else. It runs on three operating systems and has WebSockets, automation and plugins.

Pick the Crossfyre Workbench if

You work on Linux and want free tools that need no account, replay as another user and scope enforcement built in, with a scanning platform beside it.

Feature by feature

Feature CaidoCrossfyre
PricingFree Basic; Individual $20/moFree; paid features from $29/mo
PlatformsWindows, macOS and LinuxLinux only
ProtocolsHTTP and WebSocketsHTTP/1.1 only, no WebSockets
Intercept and replayIntercept and ReplayIntercept and Repeater
Fuzzing and match and replaceAutomate, Match & ReplaceNot yet
ExtensionsPlugin store and workflowsNone
Replay as another userCommunity plugins such as AutorizeBuilt in, on a paid plan
Shared team instanceOn the Team plan no
Open source no no
What it is part ofA standalone toolkitA recon and scanning platform

Every claim about the other tool is taken from its own documentation and pricing as of November 2026. Re-check before quoting a number.

When Caido is the better choice

For most people choosing a proxy today, Caido is the better choice. It runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, and the Crossfyre Workbench runs on Linux only. Caido intercepts WebSocket traffic as well as HTTP, and the Workbench speaks HTTP/1.1 and does not carry WebSockets. Caido has Automate for payload attacks and Match & Replace for rewriting traffic, and the Workbench has neither yet.

Caido is also extensible. It has a plugin store, plugins are written with web tooling, and workflows are a node-based way to build small automations. HTTPQL queries history with expressions such as resp.code.gte:500. Team plans share one instance among several testers. The Workbench at version 0.1.1 has no plugins and no shared instance, and its history has search where Caido has a query language.

When the Crossfyre Workbench is the better choice

The Workbench is narrower and makes a few different choices. Everything in its free tier works with no account: the proxy and its certificate authority, history and search, intercept, a byte-for-byte Repeater, Decoder, Comparer, the site map, a CSRF proof of concept, an upstream proxy and a client certificate per project. Projects and captured traffic stay on your disk and are not uploaded. Caido’s free Basic plan is limited to 2 projects, 7 workflows and 3 plugins.

Its paid tier is aimed at one job, access control. Replay sends a chosen request once as each identity you have written down and once as nobody, and lays the answers side by side, with a mark where a response is byte for byte the anonymous one. Scope refuses any destination you have not listed before anything is dialled, and Findings turns the requests that prove a problem into a report. In Caido, replaying as another user comes from community plugins.

The other reason is what comes with it. The paid plan those features need is a Crossfyre plan, which also runs recon and scanning on your own nodes, including automated BOLA, BFLA and BOPLA testing, and capture from Android apps.

What each one costs

Caido Basic is free forever. On its pricing page in November 2026, Individual is $20 a month in US dollars and Team is $45 per seat a month for up to 50 seats, with a discount for paying yearly and lower localized prices in some countries. Individual can also be bought as a voucher, at $200 for a year. Enterprise is quoted. Students and teachers can get a free one-year Education plan.

The Workbench is free to download and use with no account. Scope, replay as another user and findings come with any paid Crossfyre plan, which starts at Pro, $29 a month or $290 a year. That plan is the whole scanning platform and not a proxy licence. Bought only for the proxy, Caido Individual is cheaper and does more.

Standards

What it covers, and what it will not claim.

Pick a list. Every row that says yes names the class that does the work, and every row that says no says why, because a coverage matrix with no gaps in it is a brochure.

8 covered 1 partly 1 not claimed The list this engine was built against. Eight fully, one partly, and one that nothing on the outside can honestly report.

MITRE ATT&CK is deliberately not here. It describes what an adversary does across a whole intrusion, and almost all of a web scanner collapses into one technique in it. A six-row ATT&CK matrix would look impressive and tell you nothing, which is the opposite of what this section is for.

The verdict

If you are choosing a proxy and nothing else, choose Caido: it runs on three operating systems, handles WebSockets, and has automation and plugins the Workbench does not have. Choose the Crossfyre Workbench if you work on Linux, want free tools that need no account, and want replay as another user and scope enforcement built in, with a platform beside it that does the recon and scanning.

Questions people ask

Is the Crossfyre Workbench a Caido alternative?

On Linux, for intercepting, repeating and comparing requests, yes. It is younger and narrower than Caido: version 0.1.1, HTTP/1.1 only, no WebSockets, no fuzzer, no match and replace and no plugins. The parts that are its own are replay as another user, scope enforcement and a findings report, on a paid plan.

Does the Workbench run on Windows or macOS?

No. It is built for Linux on x86-64 and 64-bit ARM, as a .deb and a tarball, and is tested on Debian 12, Ubuntu 22.04 and Kali Linux. Caido has desktop builds for Windows, macOS and Linux.

Is Caido free? Is the Workbench?

Both have a free tier. Caido Basic is free forever, limited to 2 projects, 7 workflows and 3 plugins. The Workbench’s proxy, intercept, Repeater, Decoder, Comparer and site map are free with no account, and scope, replay as another user and findings need a paid Crossfyre plan.

Is either one open source?

No. Caido’s FAQ says it is not open source, and the Workbench is closed too. The open-source parts of Crossfyre are its scan engines, under Apache-2.0.

Where does my captured traffic go?

With the Workbench, projects, captured traffic and the certificate authority stay on your machine and are not uploaded. It contacts crossfyre.io to check your plan and bins.crossfyre.io for a signed list of versions, and both checks can be switched off. Caido says it does not collect data stored on your instances or your activity inside the application.

Can I test access control in either one?

Yes. In Caido it is done with community plugins; its store lists Autorize, described as automated authorization testing. In the Workbench, Replay is built in on a paid plan: it sends one request as each identity and as nobody and shows the responses side by side, with no score and no verdict.